Setting this Variable to 1 should allow this.
A Lotus Domino 6.5.4 server is configured to use negotiated SSL for outbound mail and also has the NOTES.INI parameter "RouterFallbackNonTLS=1" enabled. When Router attempts to send mail to an SMTP server that is not responding, or is otherwise unreachable, Router becomes stuck in a infinite loop.
This issue has been reported to Quality Engineering as SPR# JBAA6BALX7.
To work around the issue, you can remove the "RouterFallbackNonTLS" parameter from the NOTES.INI, or disable the parameter by setting it's value to zero(RouterFallbackNonTLS=0).